Evidence for Dash Cam Skeptics - Fleet Management

Proof for Sprint Cam Skeptics – Fleet Administration

Photograph Courtesy of J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc.

Trucking is likely one of the few industries wherein heavy tools is operated among the many normal inhabitants, away from services, and with out direct supervision. Consequently, fleet managers needed to settle for not figuring out what occurred on the street for a very long time, counting on driver suggestions concerning accidents and delays. Sprint cams have modified that and created a monumental shift within the trade for the nice.

Not solely do sprint cams present exoneration of harmless drivers, in addition they give fleet professionals alerts of poor driving situations. This permits them to educate drivers on adverse behaviors and reward them for displaying optimistic, desired driving habits. Some options even audibly alert drivers who’re fatigued, deviate from their lane, or are tailgating, including an extra layer of in-cab safety.

But, skeptics nonetheless exist. I ask you to think about concrete proof that challenges three frequent causes I hear from carriers about why they hesitate to make use of sprint cams. Let’s have a look!


  1. “Insurance coverage will cowl our prices if we’ve an accident.”

That solely works when you have sufficient insurance coverage. Many components go into insuring a fleet correctly, and sadly, carriers typically want extra insurance coverage than they’ve.

Insurance coverage is required by Federal Motor Service Security Administration (FMCSA) laws and particular person state legal guidelines. It’s the major technique carriers use to fulfill the FMCSA’s required ranges of monetary duty. The company’s guidelines require for-hire operations of any measurement or kind of auto and unsafe materials haulers to have between $750,000 and $5,000,000 in legal responsibility protection. Nonetheless, the federal minimal legal responsibility protection ranges haven’t elevated in practically 40 years.

Transportation suppliers have to assess their precise publicity to threat, not the minimal required by the state of operation or the federal authorities. It is not uncommon for lawsuit awards to enter the thousands and thousands of {dollars}. Carriers might want to make up the distinction of no matter quantity their insurance coverage supplier doesn’t cowl. For smaller operations, these lawsuit awards may cause the corporate to go underneath and stop to function. (In line with the 2022 Operational Prices of Trucking ATRI research, truckload provider insurance coverage premiums differ considerably by provider measurement. Fleets with fewer than 26 vans paid greater than twice as a lot per mile for insurance coverage as fleets with greater than 1,000 vans.)

A 2019 survey of fleets with sprint cams reported that 49% of respondents noticed a lower within the common worth of insurance coverage claims, and 61% noticed a decline within the variety of insurance coverage claims.1 Why would that be?

Carriers utilizing sprint cams can share their driving conduct knowledge and the way it’s used to enhance security with their insurance coverage suppliers and underwriters. Underwriters are the specialists in analyzing knowledge and figuring out the extent of threat for any given protection. However they’ll solely analyze the info that they’re conscious of and what’s in entrance of them. So, when knowledge is missing, the underwriter assumes it doesn’t exist, or it exists and is hidden as a result of a provider doesn’t need them to see it.



  1. “Sprint cams may damage me in court docket if my driver is at fault for an accident.”

It’s necessary to acknowledge the information: most accidents are attributable to the passenger car. The FMCSA Giant Truck and Bus Crash Information (September 2022) confirmed that in 2020, a minimum of one driver-related issue was recorded for 55% of the passenger car drivers in deadly crashes, in comparison with 32% of the massive truck drivers in deadly crashes.


“Why wouldn’t you put in a splash cam if you understand that statistically, greater than half the time, your driver in all probability will not be at fault?” states Michael Nalepka, Strategic Partnership Govt for VideoProtects® Video Occasion Monitoring System, a service of J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc.  Few can rival the sprint cam trade expertise of Nalepka. He has seen extra sprint cam movies than most and is adamant about its worth. “You’ll be able to’t get these odds wherever. The worth and ROI of sprint cams are plain.”


Video is one of the best witness in a extreme crash and might help you keep away from a multimillion-dollar verdict. A video clip can show the information and ensure that your driver was not at fault, or a minimum of contradict statements from the plaintiff. Sadly, even when you have a superior efficiency administration program, proving that your driver was not at fault will be tough with out video proof of the moments earlier than the crash.

Even if you happen to can’t totally exonerate your driver, video proof could encourage a plaintiff to settle extra rapidly and for lower than anticipated. It is because your video could present that the scenario was much less egregious than prior statements indicated.

In reality, the exoneration of even one driver concerned in a crash with important litigation threat can pay for the sprint cam funding many occasions over. Moreover, proof of the motive force’s innocence prevents you from firing a superb driver and having to rent and practice a brand new one!

Secondly, litigation situations are rising — and so are verdict awards. In November 2021, the American Transportation Analysis Institute (ATRI), Arlington, VA, shared in The Impression of Small Verdicts and Settlements on the Trucking Business that instances with a settlement or verdict of lower than $1 million had proliferated prior to now 20 years. Whereas not as financially damaging to a provider as a nuclear verdict, these smaller verdicts typically come up from groundless allegations, which video can typically contradict. Their 2020 research, Verdicts on the Trucking Business, signifies that verdict awards of over $1 million have additionally skyrocketed.

Why such important awards? That is the place you should lean in: a provider’s actions are judged in court docket by what they need to have identified and achieved, not what they took the time to seek out and proper. A provider should right any unsafe scenario that would have an effect on the motoring public. Simply since you didn’t learn about a driver’s behavior of fill within the clean doesn’t imply you aren’t liable for it.

On the flip aspect, 45% of fleets recognized decrease authorized charges and dangers of litigation as sprint cam advantages.2 As well as, these fleets diminished their unknowns (what they need to have identified and achieved) by monitoring and addressing dangerous behaviors by teaching. And it was made quite a bit simpler with in-cab video.

  1. “The price of cameras is just too excessive, and the ROI takes too lengthy to safe.”

You’ve learn in regards to the drama and {dollars} – accidents, nuclear verdicts, and harm to your model. These are the prices of NOT having sprint cameras in your fleet.

However keep in mind this: It’s essential to right any unsafe scenario that would have an effect on the motoring public. Your operation shall be scrutinized based mostly on all discoverable knowledge, not simply the accidents and citations on a driver’s document on the time of the crash.

Assembly these essential necessities is made simpler by monitoring driver conduct utilizing video. It’s a lot more durable for a plaintiff’s lawyer to show negligence when you could have a proactive teaching and coaching program based mostly on observable behaviors captured by a splash cam. Well timed detection and correction of unsafe behaviors scale back safety-related and operational prices, reduce potential legal responsibility, and may scale back the impression of litigation if a significant crash happens.

Defend your fleet with sprint cameras. Obtain the free Sprint Cam Return on Funding whitepaper. Don’t let a single accident sabotage your fleet. Our trade cannot afford to lose any extra fleets to a nuclear verdict.

VideoProtects is a product and repair of J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc. J. J. Keller is the trusted supply for DOT/Transportation, OSHA/Office Security, Human Sources, Building Security and Hazmat/Hazardous Supplies regulation compliance. J. J. Keller helps you improve security consciousness, scale back threat, comply with greatest practices, enhance security coaching, and keep present with altering laws. www.videoprotects.com

1Leveraging the Advantages of Sprint Cam Expertise. J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc. and Freightwaves. November, 2019.

2 Ibid.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.