Werner Appeal of $89.7 Million Verdict Denied

Werner Enchantment of $89.7 Million Verdict Denied


[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

A Texas state courtroom has denied an enchantment by Werner Enterprises Inc. of an $89.7 million jury verdict in a case involving a 2014 deadly crash.

“We now have inspected the file and discover no error within the judgment,” seven of the 9 justices wrote in a Might 18 opinion. “We order the judgment of the courtroom under affirmed. We order appellants, Werner Enterprises, Inc., and [truck driver] Shiraz Ali, collectively and severally, to pay all prices incurred on this enchantment.” Two justices wrote dissenting opinions within the case.

Werner couldn’t be instantly be reached for remark.

The enchantment, which was based mostly on authorized points starting from admissions of proof to the jury’s award of future medical care bills, had languished on the Texas Fourteenth Courtroom of Appeals in Houston for greater than 4 years.

The case stretches again to a 2018 trial during which a Houston jury returned the large verdict — one of many highest ever towards a motor service — in reference to the 2014 crash. In it, a pickup truck pushed by a buddy of the plaintiff misplaced management on a slick interstate, traveled throughout the freeway median and collided with a Werner tractor touring on the alternative stretch of street. Werner appealed the $89.7 million verdict in October 2018.

It stays unclear if Werner plans additional appeals.

Werner’s attorneys wrote in a courtroom pleading: “On the time of this accident, Shiraz Ali was continuing in his lane, in command of a Werner tractor-trailer and properly under the pace restrict, when the [plaintiff’s] car all of a sudden careened into his path, leaving him no time to keep away from a collision.” Nevertheless, the decrease courtroom jury discovered each Werner and Ali liable and assessed the big award, in keeping with courtroom paperwork.

The plaintiff’s legal professional within the case, Eric Penn, argued in courtroom that the Werner driver was inexperienced, driving too quick, and shouldn’t even have been driving within the icy circumstances current on the time. He additionally charged that Werner was negligent for failing to adequately practice and supervise Ali for working in unhealthy climate.

In response to the appeals courtroom, the jury heard proof that Werner teaches drivers that they’ve the discretion whether or not to come back to a crawl or cease in icy circumstances.”

In a dissenting opinion, Chief Justice Tracy Christopher stated the bulk didn’t handle related points raised within the enchantment.

“I agree with the bulk that the proof helps a discovering that [driver] Ali was negligent and that his negligence was a proximate reason for the accidents,” Christopher wrote. “As a result of the bulk has failed to handle meritorious complaints that have been preserved within the trial courtroom, re-urged on enchantment, and dictate the reversal of the trial courtroom’s judgment, I respectfully dissent.”

Werner Enterprises ranks No. 17 on the Transport Matters High 100 record of the most important for-hire carriers in North America

Need extra information? Take heed to immediately’s every day briefing under or go right here for more information:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.